| Week 1 | |||||
| Date | Home | Away | Time | Site | Result |
| Friday, September 11, 2015 | Warwick Valley | St. Peter’s | 7:00 PM | Warwick Valley | 26-6 SP |
| Newburgh | Archbishop Stepinac | 7:00 PM | Newburgh | 31-0 AS | |
| Holy Cross | Monroe Woodbury | 7:00 PM | Monroe Woodbury | 10-0 MW | |
| Fordham Prep | Christ the King | 8:30 PM | Coffey Field | 27-20 CTK | |
| Saturday, September 12, 2015 | Holy Trinity | St. Francis (Buffalo) | 1:00 PM | Holy Trinity | 49-19 SF |
| St. John the Baptist | St. Joseph’s by the Sea | 1:30 PM | St. John the Baptist | 20-17 SJB | |
| Chaminade | Poly Prep | 1:30 PM | Chaminade | 42-13 PP | |
| Iona Prep | Brunswick | 1:30 PM | Iona Prep | 26-18 BW | |
| Monsignor Farrell | St. Joe’s (Buffalo) | 1:30 PM | Monsignor Farrell | 38-17 MF | |
| Mount St. Michael | Xavier | 1:30 PM | Mount St. Michael | 21-6 Xavier | |
| Delbarton | St. Anthony’s | 2:00 PM | Delbarton | 28-21 SA | |
| Kennedy Catholic | Cardinal Spellman | 2:00 PM | Kennedy Catholic | 38-25 CS | |
| Cardinal Hayes | Cornwall | 3:00 PM | Rooftop | 37-14 CH | |
| St. Dominic | Hopkins | 3:00 PM | CIBF, Bayville | 14-6 Hopkins | |
| St. Francis Prep | Kellenberg | 7:00 PM | Mitchel Field | 35-6 KM | |
| Xaverian | Nazareth | 7:00 PM | Aviator | 48-0 Xaverian | |
December 5, 2023